Four states sue the federal government over tax cut law

Despite the fact that millions of citizens are enjoying the “crumbs” tossed to them via the tax bill passed last December, four states are angry over the cap on state and local tax deductions allowed on Federal taxes, saying that it exceeds the taxing authority of Congress, and that the new tax law is unconstitutional. The reason, of course, is that these states have extremely high levels of taxation (some might say punitive) – much higher than those in most of our states. The four states suing are (no surprise) New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, and Maryland.

National Review

Under federal tax law, filers are allowed to deduct property taxes (the local part) and either state income or sales taxes. But under the Tax Cut and Jobs Act (TCJA), the SALT deduction is now capped at $10,000. This deduction had been particularly valuable in high-tax, high-house-price states such as California and the four now suing the federal government.

Republicans limited the deduction for two reasons. First, doing so helped to offset some of the lost tax revenue from lower rates. And second, the deduction distorts the economy, acting as a subsidy for high-tax (and, yes, Democratic-leaning) states. When a state raises its taxes, the federal government ends up assuming part of the burden, because residents are able to deduct their higher payments from their federal taxable income.

Unsurprisingly, high-tax blue states have been fighting tooth and nail against this reform. This latest argument might be the silliest yet, as it makes no sense economically or legally. The four states claim that limiting the SALT deduction violates both the Tenth and 16th Amendments, as well as Congress’s Article I taxing powers. The Tenth Amendment reserves unspecified powers to the states, while the 16th Amendment provides the federal government a wider ability to charge income taxes. In Article I, meanwhile, Congress is given certain taxing powers but limited in what it can force on states.

The Tax Policy Center estimated that 84 percent of the benefit of the SALT deduction before the TCJA went to households in the top 20 percent of income earners. Blue states that might be expected to favor a tax reform that increased the progressivity of the tax code (meaning it tilts the tax burden toward the rich) are instead busy inventing ways to preserve this deduction for their rich residents. This lawsuit has little merit other than to serve as a clear signal that political leaders in these states have joined the anti-Trump Resistance.

All of which goes to once again prove that it is the Democrats who want as much money as they can possibly extract from the citizens to use as they “see fit”. Who cares if the little guy is benefiting from a reduction in his taxes, and that his employer is raising salaries and bonuses because their tax burden is decreased? /s

This entry was posted in Government, News, Politics, Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Four states sue the federal government over tax cut law

  1. James Fish has some fishy lips. We used to use WM for our trash collection. They raised the price to CRAZY, so we found a local guy much cheaper. He also gives us a discount because we separate our cans and cardboard. We could get even less expensive, but the guy we have now is very good! Northeast Georgia Sanitation, Clarkesville, GA. You are the best!

    Liked by 2 people

    • I can’t help but laugh at these dems finding out they have to pay so much more tax, just because they live in mansions in swanky neighborhoods! HA!

      Liked by 1 person

    • czarowniczy says:

      The Quarter used to be world infamous for being one of the filthiest places in the civilized world, the City bosses said there wasn’t anything that could be done.
      Just after Katrina a local trash service underbid the cronies and said it could outperform them. Over the next few months it not only efficiently picked up the trash but cleaned the filthy streets regularly AND sprayed them with a perfume that made them smell not only good but great. At a cost less than the usual folks.
      The owner started expanding out and…how shall we say…showing up high ranking political hacks and just like that he was out of a contract. New contractors do a passable job but no where near what the old guy did. The Quarter still smells like the Quarter but the pols are happy.


  2. Menagerie says:

    I am surprised California isn’t in there.


  3. czarowniczy says:

    Ahhhhh…so the states are saying the Feds have no right to cap deductions on Federal taxes. Okay…I suppose states that have been bleeding jobs for decades must have developed some interesting logic to help their denial process.
    Wanna bet a beer on what the outcome will be?


  4. mntaxpros says:

    Informative post.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.